What To Know About Restoring Historic Properties in Kentucky

Anderson & Rodgers Construction • July 17, 2026

From the Mary Todd Lincoln House in Lexington to the Historic Locust Grove in Louisville, Kentucky, there’s a picturesque collection of historic properties throughout our state. While our award-winning team at Anderson & Rodgers Construction enjoys visiting these places as guests, more and more Kentuckians are seeking to restore historic buildings.

While these projects aren’t necessarily the simplest tasks, they’re certainly rewarding for our communities. So, here’s what you need to know about historical restoration.

1. Preserve What Makes a Building Historic

For most historic properties, applying a coat of paint simply isn’t enough to restore them to their former glory. Many properties require extensive renovations to ensure they’re structurally sound, but that doesn’t mean you should ignore the blueprints. By preserving what you can of a historical property, you can recreate the space as it was, while meeting modern safety standards.

Fresh and modern kitchen with fashionable finishes in a historic renovation by Anderson & Rodgers Construction

However, when seeking to restore a historical property, it’s necessary to contact your State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) or the Local Municipal Historic Board/Commission, such as the Kentucky Heritage Council (KHC), Heritage Ohio, or the Florida Trust for Historic Preservation.

Here are some quick good-to-knows when it comes to a historic property renovation:

  • Do not remove or change character-defining elements.
  • Do preserve distinctive craftsmanship, original construction techniques where possible, materials, and finishes.
  • Do document materials and features of the historical period before altering or removing them.

2. Repair Original Features Before Replacing

Certain original pieces of a property will be lost to time. But if you’re able to restore rather than replace, it will give that notable historic touch, bringing the past into the future for appreciation.

A hidden pantry within the brick walls of a historic remodel by Anderson & Rodgers Construction

Additionally, repairing instead of replacing, when possible, preserves the property’s authenticity and structural integrity. This step may often include navigating ways to clean wood features, masonry, plaster walls, and metals.

You can approach this step with these tips:

  • Do match the original design, color, texture, and materials when possible; if you must replace, do so with similar materials.
  • Do use the gentlest treatment methods available for the material you’re restoring.
  • Do ensure that any alterations you make are reversible to avoid permanent mistakes.

3. Maintain the Property’s Historical Integrity

If you walked into a historical building and the tour guides or the wall plaque stated that what you were looking at was nowhere near the original, the experience wouldn’t feel authentic. Sticking as closely as possible to the original building’s design, layout, and features is the best way to uphold this requirement.

You can also ensure historical integrity with the following:

  • Do support replacement of missing features with clear documentary or physical evidence.
  • Do research the property thoroughly to avoid creating a false sense of history.
  • Do not construct designs that were never done historically in the property.

4. Trust a Construction Company With Historic Reno Experience

Participating in a historic building restoration project requires a level of care and attention to detail that should be entrusted to local builders with extensive experience in the field. Our team at Anderson & Rodgers Construction has helped restore several historic properties, making us an excellent choice for Kentuckians seeking a residential and commercial construction company they can trust.

Stylish sitting room in a historic remodel, by Anderson & Rodgers Construction, with exposed brick walls

From museums to old homes, we’re here to breathe new life into your property while preserving its historical integrity and complying with local building regulations.

A few examples of our historic renovation portfolio include:

  • Pine Mountain Shelter, a 100-year-old log and stone structure.
  • John G. King Building, a historic building façade constructed in the 1870s, located in downtown Lexington.
  • The Sweet Boutique, a renovation of a historic building dating back to 1906, repurposed as a café and bakery in Cynthiana, KY.

Our talented team has also worked on multiple residential historic remodels in our community, including builds on S. Ashland Avenue and N. Hanover Avenue in Lexington, KY.

Find the Best Team for Historic Restoration Near Lexington, KY

Renovating a historic building is how Kentucky’s history can still be enjoyed or studied today. If you’re looking for a local construction company that you can trust for your restoration project, our expert team at Anderson & Rodgers Construction is ready to connect with you.

Contact us to schedule your free consultation and discuss your restoration vision.

Anderson & Rodgers Construction proudly serves the greater Lexington and Central Kentucky areas, including Versailles, Georgetown, Richmond, and Winchester, as well as Cincinnati, OH.

An elevated backyard patio with comfortable seating, a fire pit, greenery, and a custom pergola
By Anderson & Rodgers Construction June 16, 2026
Explore three major benefits of adding a pergola to your outdoor space. Contact Anderson & Rodgers Construction for pergolas installation near Lexington, KY!
A well-designed and luxurious covered patio with outdoor seating and a kitchen at a residential home
By Anderson & Rodgers Construction May 21, 2026
Explore the differences between decks and patios to determine which outdoor living space is right for you. Contact us near Lexington, KY, for more information!
Small restaurant undergoing renovations with blueprints in the foreground.
By Anderson & Rodgers Construction April 21, 2026
Ready to renovate your business in Lexington, Kentucky? Here are the signs it’s time for a commercial business renovation for your KY business. Contact us today.
Outdoor patio remodel outside of home near Lexington, KY
By Anderson & Rodgers Construction March 31, 2026
Thinking of starting outdoor remodeling near Lexington, KY? Learn when the best time to start is and schedule your consultation with our team to get started.
Interior designer holding flooring and color samples with a design layout.
By Anderson & Rodgers Construction February 27, 2026
Thinking of upgrading your Lexington, Kentucky, home? See why our experts recommend an interior designer. Contact us today to learn more and get started.
Remodeled kitchen with wood flooring, cabinets, and kitchen island.
By Anderson & Rodgers Construction January 27, 2026
Ready for a fresh start? Explore home remodeling trends for 2026 and contact our team at Anderson & Rodgers Construction serving Lexington, Kentucky, today.
New home addition with a seating area filled with furniture.
By Anderson & Rodgers Construction December 30, 2025
Thinking of a home addition near Lexington, KY? Here are the signs it’s time and why Anderson & Rodgers Construction is the perfect choice for the task. Contact us!
Primary bathroom with modern tub, shower, and vanity near Lexington, KY
By Anderson & Rodgers Construction November 19, 2025
Discover the ins and outs of getting a master bathroom remodel near Lexington, KY. Contact us today to learn about master bathroom remodel ideas and more.
Contemporary luxury kitchen with island, marble countertops, and appliances near Lexington, KY
By Anderson & Rodgers Construction October 16, 2025
Deciding on whether to invest in a luxury kitchen can be overwhelming. Here's how you know if your custom kitchen remodel is worth it near Lexington, KY.
 Logo image for First Place in Best of Lexington Winner for 2025.
By Anderson & Rodgers Construction September 29, 2025
Are you deciding on a general contractor for your Lexington, Kentucky, home? See why Anderson & Rodgers, the Best of Lexington 2025 Winners, is a top choice.